Set Performance Expectations for Higher Performance and Increased Engagement

Cathie Leimbach • September 27, 2021

How many times have you thought or said, "of course, my employees know what to do, and I don't understand why they don't do what is expected?" Sound familiar? Most leaders have thought this more than once. And here is an interesting statistic – research shows that only 50% of employees (including managers) know what is expected of them.

 

Research shows us something else that is important – 60% to 65% of managers are disengaged, without a clear understanding of what expectations are for their performance.

 

When employees don't know what they are supposed to do, why it is important and how their performance impacts their team, they are less engaged. That means overall performance is negatively impacted, goals aren’t met, and employees are less likely to make the additional effort to get things done.

 

80% of employees agree that they are 8 times more likely to be engaged when their managers set and communicate clear performance expectations.

 

Managers are in the best position to make sure employees have clarity about what is expected from them. And it starts with these three questions – as a manager:

  • do you know what is expected of you for your overall performance?
  • do you know what is expected from you about how you lead your team?
  • do your team members understand what is expected, how to do it right, and why their performance is important?

 

As a manager, understanding what is expected of you is an essential first step. Which means you need to understand it for yourself first. Talk to your leadership to be clear about how to be successful in both your job and as a leader. You will set the bar and demonstrate high performance for your team.

 

Steps to creating clear performance expectations with your team include:

  • collaboratively setting performance expectations with your employees. When employees have input, they are more likely to "own" their performance and clearly understand what performance is required.


  • articulating clearly each expectation. For example:

Instead of: "get the data about X from the accounting department":

Say this: "get the data about X from the accounting department (what). We will use that data to analyze profitability, which is essential to fulfill our 3rd quarter goals in the strategic plan (why). We will need that data by October 8 (when).


  • create and communicate high expectations to develop more inspired employees. Let each direct report understand what sets high performers apart and how performance that meets or exceeds expectations impacts the company's overall success.

 

Schedule routine meetings with each direct report, no less than once every quarter, to communicate performance expectations, collaboratively determine how employees can improve their overall performance, and discuss why strong performance is crucial.

 

You will have the most significant impact as a leader by enabling top performance from your team members by helping them understand what is expected of them and ensuring they have the support and professional development needed to accomplish those goals. 

By Cathie Leimbach • November 17, 2026
“Want me to stay for the first changeover?” Denise asked. “I’ve got it,” Luis said. Luis had run the packaging line for three years. When Denise asked him to handle the changeover for a new carton size, he’d volunteered before she’d finished explaining the job. She figured he was ready. Twenty minutes later, the line was still stopped. Luis had adjusted the guides and loaded the cartons, but he hadn’t run the first carton through. He was waiting for someone to check the settings. “You’ve done changeovers before,” Denise said. “What’s holding you up?” “Yeah, just never with this size,” Luis said. “Can you check the first one with me? I want to make sure I’m looking for the right things.” Denise had heard “I’ve got it” and assumed Luis could handle the whole job on his own. Luis was eager to take it on. Yet, he wasn’t quite ready to do it without some help. Leadership Tips for Assessing Task Readiness Competence and Commitment 1. As the leader, assess your employee’s readiness for the task. Look at what you’ve seen the employee do in the past. What parts of this task have they not done before? Denise had watched Luis set up the line and check the first carton on familiar sizes. She’d seen him set up the new size, too. She still needed to see him check it. His willingness to volunteer told her he wanted the assignment. Watching him work would help her assess what he could do independently. 2. Ask employees to assess their own readiness for the task. Explain the specific assignment. Ask, “Which parts of this assignment have you done before? Which parts are new to you? How do you think that part could be done? What help might you need? How do you feel about taking this on?” Give the employee time to answer. Luis could have told Denise he was eager to learn the new changeover yet wanted someone with him for the first-carton check. 3. Compare assessments and agree on how you’ll supervise. If your assessment and your employee’s assessment of their readiness differ, discuss your differences. Ask the employee for examples of when he has done the task independently or when he has needed help. Come to agreement on whether you will leave him to work independently or where you will check in or coach. If Luis indicates he isn’t confident about doing the first-carton check, Denise could say, "Since you are skilled with most of the setup process, go ahead with that yourself. Call me over when you are ready for the first-carton check.” Bottom Line Give people room to do the tasks they can handle and be there for the tasks they’re still learning. A short conversation can help you both see where that line is. Conversation is Where Leadership Happens™ How do you know when to step in and when to give someone more room? Bring a real situation to our Workplace Conversations Clinic on December 21 . We’ll discuss asking employees where they feel ready, sharing what you’ve observed, and agreeing on the support they need.  Reserve your spot for the December 21 Workplace Conversations Clinic Here
By Cathie Leimbach • November 10, 2026
For the tenth day in a row, production missed its target. Barry, the production manager, was frustrated and worried. Customer orders were piling up, inventory was running low, and he had no idea how to get things back on track. Even the VP of Manufacturing and HR had no helpful answers. Meanwhile, Joe, one of the line supervisors, couldn't understand why Barry was so upset. He'd heard through the grapevine that sales were down. So why was producing less such a big deal? Barry was baffled. He'd told his supervisors to increase production. Why weren't they pushing their teams harder? He pulled up the AI summary from Monday's "What's Up This Week" meeting. There it was. He'd asked the supervisors to produce more than last week because a large customer order had to ship the following Monday. But had he made his expectations clear? Barry thought he'd given a goal. Joe thought he'd heard a suggestion. Neither knew they weren't on the same page. Sound familiar? When expectations are fuzzy, even good employees miss the mark. The result: frustrated managers, confused employees, missed targets, and disappointed customers. LEADERSHIP TIPS: THREE STEPS TO STRONGER PERFORMANCE 1. Make expectations crystal clear. Explain what needs to be done, by when, and why it matters. Instead of saying "produce more," Barry could have said, "We need 200 additional widgets by Friday to fill a 500-widget customer order that ships Monday." Then he could have asked each supervisor what their line could realistically produce and what support they needed. A two-way conversation builds clarity and commitment. 2. Monitor progress daily. Don't wait until Friday to discover the team is behind. Review production results with supervisors every day. Compare actual output with the weekly goal, and recognize progress along the way. Ask, "Are we on track? What might keep us from reaching our target?" 3. Take corrective action before shortfalls grow. When production falls behind, don't just demand better results. Start a conversation. Ask, "What's getting in the way? How can we catch up? What help do you need from me?" Then work out a plan together, agree on who's doing what, and follow up to make sure it happens. Strong performance doesn't come from pushing people harder. It comes from clear expectations, regular monitoring, and shared accountability. When leaders explain what matters, listen to their people, and help remove roadblocks, employees are better equipped and more motivated to deliver. Conversation is Where Leadership Happens™ Say what matters. Ask what's in the way. Agree on next steps. Missed targets, fuzzy expectations, or a talk you keep postponing? Bring it to the Workplace Conversations Clinic on November 16. We'll discuss how to have that conversation with kindness and clarity. Register Here