Managing at Work is Like Teaching School

Cathie Leimbach • April 25, 2023

In a busy workplace, managers can be tempted to treat every employee the same despite the diversity of experiences, strengths, and preferences among human beings. The reasons might be not wanting to show favoritism, not making it a priority to get to know each person as an individual, or simply believing that the best management style is the best in all situations.

Let’s think back to our childhood experiences at school. Did everyone in our second-grade class read at the same level? Did all our high school classmates love English literature or struggle with geometry as much as we did?  Was it only the kids who didn’t do their homework or study for the test who got Bs, Cs, or Ds? When we got C on the first science test, what helped us get an A on our first quarter report card?

Sometimes, reading the textbook, completing assignments, and studying for tests made the difference. Other times, putting in the extra effort only raised our grade from a C- to a C. How discouraging! Often,  it was the teacher who made the difference. At the University of Guelph, the outstanding reputation of one first year chemistry professor led to his classroom always being full.  Rather than attending a different professor’s chemistry class as their official schedule directed, many students crowded around the open classroom door to hear the preferred professor explain chemistry in a way that made sense to teenagers. The Oberlin High School teacher who was recently awarded National Teacher of the Year captured the hearts of his students by talking one-on-one with those who seemed troubled, attending athletes’ games, and being available for extra help. His interest in the students’ success helped these young people with school and with life. Many flourished due to his emotional, academic, and life-relevant support.

Many students succeed because teachers took notice, offered time, and taught lessons in different ways to serve varied needs and learning styles. The most appreciated managers at work exhibit similar attitudes and behaviors. They invest in the success of their employees. They explain and re-explain. They train and retrain. They praise progress and achievement. They listen to employees’ workplace or life pains. They set expectations and patiently support individuals along the road to fulfilling expectations.  And sometimes, they point individuals towards a path that better suits them.

Effective leaders at home, at school, or at work recognize that people are unique individuals. They pay attention to human differences and modify their leadership strategy to appropriately guide each-and-every valuable human being to success. 

How skilled are you in meeting your team members where they are and supporting them along their success journey? What steps could you take to enhance your leadership practices? Conversational Management may be a right fit for you. Check it out by contacting me at cathie@agonleadership.com.

Why New Tools Don’t Change Behavior

By Cathie Leimbach • January 27, 2026
New tools promise big results. New software, dashboards, and systems all look great on paper. But months later, many leaders are still asking, “Why hasn’t much changed?” Because tools don’t change behavior — leadership does. A system can organize work, but it can’t create ownership. It can’t set expectations. It can’t follow through. Without strong leadership habits, even the best tools just make problems more visible. What really drives results? Clear expectations Consistent follow-through Helpful feedback Leaders who model the right behavior When those are missing, people work around the tool instead of with it. Adoption drops. Frustration rises. And the old problems stay. So the better question isn’t, “What tool do we need next?” It’s, “Do our leadership habits support the results we expect?”  👉 Join our 60-minute Leadership Conversation to explore the habits that actually drive performance.

If Nothing Changes, What Will This Cost?

By Cathie Leimbach • January 20, 2026
When things feel “manageable,” leaders often continue with status quo. People are busy. Work gets done. But small issues quietly add up. Rework becomes normal. Deadlines stretch. Decisions take longer. None of it feels like a crisis, but together it eats away at time, energy, and profit. Inconsistent leadership makes it worse. When expectations change from day to day or from one manager to another, people stop giving their best. Some coast. Some get frustrated. Some start looking elsewhere. Turnover rises, along with hiring and training costs. The warning signs are usually right in front of us: Work keeps getting redone. Managers avoid tough conversations around poor performance. Good people are doing less than they could. Progress feels slower than it should. The real question isn’t, “Can we live with this?” It’s, “What is this costing us if nothing changes?” 👉 Join our 60-minute Leadership Conversation to explore how today’s patterns may be impacting your results — and what small shifts could make a big difference.