Who's Responsible for Employee Success?
Cathie Leimbach • July 15, 2020
This is a subtitle for your new post
When I facilitate client meetings, every person in the room shares their perspective on the matter at hand and contributes ideas of how to move forward. Managers are often shocked at the positive energy and quality of input from their staff. Why are so many leaders, managers, and supervisors unaware of their staff’s potential and their value to the organization?
One reason is that few managers ask questions. There is a tendency for supervisors to give their staff day-by-day, or even hour-by-hour, specific instructions on what to do next, or they leave their staff alone to figure everything out by themselves. Few managers invest a lot of time using an intermediate approach. Daily or weekly two-way conversations between staff members and supervisors are relatively uncommon. Without such discussions, supervisors are unaware of their staff’s strengths and interests so can’t leverage their potential.
And, when staff don’t interact with others at work, they don’t feel valued. Their enthusiasm and productivity drop. Then, managers get frustrated with employee apathy and mediocre productivity.
Leaders push staff to work harder. Staff complain that managers aren't helpful or expectations aren't clear. Decades of Gallup research has revealed that the staff's assessment of the problem is pretty accurate. 70% of the factors that contribute to disappointing morale, engagement, productivity, and profit are the responsibility of managers.
So, what is the root cause of mediocre organizational outcomes? IT’S THE MANAGER!
Effective managers have servant hearts. They develop the skills needed to help their staff be the best they can be. They manage by asking questions that inspire great conversations and by becoming competent in the fifteen core skills of effective management. Unfortunately, this description of an effective manager does not describe the majority of managers.
What will you do this week to move beyond average? What is your next step to becoming a manager who leads with excellence and develops a healthy, high performance workplace team?
Great leaders don’t just manage tasks—they build people up. Christine Caine’s leadership advice reminds us that believing in others is one of the most powerful things we can do. When leaders believe in people, they help unlock potential that might otherwise stay hidden. It’s not about perfection—it’s about possibility. Believing the best of others means choosing trust over suspicion. Instead of assuming someone will fail, assume they’ll rise. This mindset creates a culture of encouragement, not fear. People work harder when they know their leader sees their strengths and believes they can grow. Leadership isn’t about being the smartest person in the room. It’s about helping others shine. That starts with listening, showing respect, and giving people room to learn. Mistakes will happen—but leaders who believe in their team use those moments to teach, not tear down. Christine Caine’s approach is simple but powerful: speak life, not doubt. Expect excellence, but lead with grace. When leaders believe in people and believe the best of them, they build teams that are confident, creative, and committed. In the end, leadership is less about control and more about trust. And trust begins with belief in people. Want a quick visual summary? Check out Better Leadership Starts with Belief , for a clear, inspiring breakdown you can share with your team.
Based on insights from James Hewitt's "Regenerative Performance" Something's not adding up in today's workplace. While companies demand more from their teams, the results tell a concerning story. Research shows that 50% of employees now show clear signs of burnout, and an alarming 73% feel disconnected from their work. James Hewitt, performance expert and author of "Regenerative Performance," points to a critical mismatch. We're asking people to perform at peak levels without giving them what they need to recover and recharge. Think of it like a smartphone. You can't expect your phone to run at full power all day without plugging it in. Yet that's exactly what we're doing to our workforce. We pile on meetings, deadlines, and pressure while cutting back on the very things that restore energy: breaks, development time, and meaningful connection. The solution isn't working less—it's working smarter. Hewitt's research reveals that sustainable high performance comes from balancing intense effort with intentional recovery. Teams that build in time to recharge actually outperform those that push through exhaustion. Smart leaders are already making the shift. They're protecting their people's energy as carefully as they manage their budgets. Because burned-out employees don't just hurt themselves—they hurt the bottom line too. Want to dive deeper into this issue? View The Burnout Crisis to understand the full scope of this workplace challenge. "Sustainable high performance comes from the rhythm of oscillation—not from the intensity of effort alone." —James Hewitt